The Absolute Best Cheesecake in Colorado Springs [Updated 2025]

Every forkful of creamy cheesecake tells a story, and as someone who’s indulged in countless slices around town, I’m ready to share my favorites after tasting my way through 12 top spots. Whether you’re a lifelong fan of this decadent dessert or just curious about the hype, I can assure you that Colorado Springs has some hidden gems that will make your taste buds dance.

With a keen eye for flavor and texture, I’ve scrutinized each bite, ensuring that only the very best makes the cut. So, grab your fork and get ready to discover where to find the most indulgent, mouthwatering cheesecake right here in our beautiful city!

Mary's Mountain Cookies

Highlights
Amazing aroma upon entry
Wide variety of cookie options
Perfect portion sizes
Adorable cookie designs
Potential freshness issues

Mary's Mountain Cookies is a delightful little gem that will capture your senses right from the moment you step inside. The inviting aroma of freshly baked cookies fills the air, making it nearly impossible to resist the urge to indulge. While this shop is primarily known for its cookies, I was intrigued to discover they also offer a unique cheesecake twist that deserves some attention.

The variety of cookie options is staggering, showcasing both classic flavors and whimsical creations that make for perfect dessert accompaniments. My personal favorite was the peppermint chocolate cheesecake cookie, which beautifully balanced the richness of cheesecake with the comforting nostalgia of a holiday treat.

Each cookie is a satisfying size, ensuring that you can enjoy the flavors without an overwhelming sugar rush. Plus, the adorable designs, like mini snowmen and festive colors, make them a feast for the eyes as well.

However, a word of caution: I did notice some freshness issues on my last visit, so be mindful of when you go. Overall, if you’re looking for a playful twist on the traditional cheesecake experience in Colorado Springs, make sure to stop by Mary's Mountain Cookies. Who knew cheesecakes could come in cookie form?

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Colorado Springs.

Marigold Cafe & Bakery

Highlights
Phenomenal brownie cheesecake
Excellent service experience
Attentive and friendly staff
Cozy atmosphere
Delicious French Onion soup

As I stepped into Marigold Cafe & Bakery, I was enveloped by a cozy atmosphere, perfect for indulging in a sweet treat. The friendly staff welcomed me with warm smiles, setting the tone for what would be a delightful culinary adventure. After much deliberation, I decided to dive into their phenomenal brownie cheesecake. It was a decadent masterpiece that perfectly fused the rich flavors of chocolate and cream cheese. Each bite melted in my mouth, leaving me craving more.

Not only was the cheesecake a star, but I also indulged in their delicious French Onion soup. It was the ideal pairing, balancing comfort and flavor beautifully. Whenever I visit a new café, the service experience is paramount, and the attentive staff at Marigold truly went above and beyond, ensuring my time there was nothing short of extraordinary.

In a town bursting with options, Marigold Cafe & Bakery stands out, not just for their desserts but for creating a welcoming space that encourages patrons to savor every moment. I left with a smile, a full belly, and a vow to return soon. If you're on the hunt for cheesecake magic, this gem is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Colorado Springs.

Sweet Elizabeth's Organics

Highlights
Gluten and Dairy Free Specialties
Delicious Lunch Options
Family-Friendly Atmosphere
Exciting Bakery Treats
Impressive Food Allergy Accommodations

Sweet Elizabeth's Organics is a delightful gem tucked away in Colorado Springs, where the allure of creamy cheesecakes marries seamlessly with a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere. Walking into the café, I was greeted by the sweet aroma of baked goods that just made my taste buds dance with anticipation.

What sets this place apart isn't just their range of gluten and dairy-free cheesecakes—it's the sheer variety that caters to everyone’s tastes! I was particularly enchanted by the rich, velvety texture of their signature cheesecake, which, despite being dairy-free, had a decadent creaminess that could rival traditional recipes. You won’t miss the dairy, I promise!

But let’s not forget their exciting lunch options that offer a perfect prelude to dessert. It’s a balanced experience that makes you feel good about indulging. Add to that their impressive food allergy accommodations, and you have a bakery that truly welcomes all.

In a city that loves its desserts, Sweet Elizabeth's Organics stands out not only for delicious cheesecake but for an ethos that champions health without compromising on flavor. I left with a happy heart—and a cheesecake to go!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Colorado Springs.

La Baguette

Highlights
Amazing French pastries
Delicious baguette sandwiches
Seasonal specials available
Excellent for lunch dates
Wide variety of sweets

La Baguette is an enchanting spot that transports you straight to a quaint French café. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly baked goods, making it clear that this was no ordinary café. Yes, they offer amazing French pastries and delicious baguette sandwiches, but let me tell you about their cheesecake!

I opted for their seasonal cheesecake, which was a luscious blend of tangy cream cheese and a rich, buttery crust that crumbled delightfully with each bite. The texture was creamy yet velvety, and the topping was a sweet surprise that complemented the cheesecake perfectly. It's obvious that they pay close attention to quality, and you can taste the care in every morsel.

What makes La Baguette special is that it’s not just a place to grab a quick treat—it's ideal for a relaxing lunch date or a leisurely afternoon. Their wide variety of sweets keeps me coming back for more. If you’re in Colorado Springs and craving cheesecake that feels indulgently French, I highly recommend stopping by La Baguette. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Colorado Springs.

Sasquatch Cookies

Highlights
Friendly counter staff
High-quality delicious cookies
Reasonable prices around $5
Hidden gem in shopping plaza
Offers dog cookies too

Sasquatch Cookies in Colorado Springs is an unexpected gem that caught me by surprise during my cheesecake quest. Nestled in a charming shopping plaza, this delightful spot has a friendly counter staff that immediately makes you feel at home. Don’t let the name fool you, though; while their high-quality delicious cookies are the star of the show, they also graciously offer a cheesecake that deserves a moment in the spotlight.

I indulged in a slice of their special cheesecake—a heavenly creation that beautifully balances creaminess with a light touch of sweetness. Each bite was like a hug for my taste buds, offering a smooth, rich texture that could easily satisfy anyone's dessert cravings. And for just about five bucks, it’s an excellent value that won’t break the bank!

To top it off, the atmosphere is cozy, making it a perfect spot to unwind with a dessert after exploring the bustling streets of Colorado Springs. Plus, pet owners will appreciate the extra treat options for their furry friends. Whether you're there for the cookies or the cheesecake, Sasquatch Cookies is a must-visit on your culinary adventure!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Colorado Springs.

Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe

Highlights
Great brunch spot
Fresh and flavorful menu
Friendly and attentive service
Dog-friendly patio
Delicious coffee options

Nestled in the stunning backdrop of Garden of the Gods, the Market and Cafe is not just a delightful brunch spot; it's a bit of a hidden gem for those on the cheesecake quest. As I settled onto their dog-friendly patio, the friendly and attentive service set an inviting tone, making me feel right at home.

With a menu bursting with fresh and flavorful options, I was eager to dive into their cheesecake offerings. And let me tell you, this cheesecake was a revelation! Impeccably creamy yet light, each bite melted in my mouth, leaving me craving just one more slice. The subtle hints of vanilla and a perfectly balanced sweetness made this dessert a true standout.

To complement my cheesecake experience, I couldn't resist their delicious coffee options, which paired splendidly and enhanced the delightful flavors. It’s the kind of place where you want to linger a little longer, savoring both the scenery and the treats.

If you find yourself in Colorado Springs, Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe is a must-visit for cheesecake enthusiasts. It's where the charm of the cafe meets the deliciously decadent world of cheesecake!

You might also want to check out the best pho in Colorado Springs.

La Baguette Cafe and Espresso Bar

Highlights
Fabulous baked goods
Amazing breakfast sandwiches
Beautiful ambiance
Consistent quality over years
Great for low-key meals

When I stepped into La Baguette Cafe and Espresso Bar, I was immediately captivated by the charming ambiance, perfectly complementing their vast selection of baked goods. The café exudes warmth and an inviting atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for a delightful breakfast or a relaxed afternoon treat. As I scanned the menu, the promise of their fabulous cheesecake called to me, teasing my taste buds with the prospect of a rich and creamy indulgence.

Now, let’s talk about the cheesecake. I opted for their classic version, and it did not disappoint. The moment I took my first bite, I was greeted by a velvety texture that simply melted in my mouth. It perfectly balanced sweetness with a hint of tanginess, showcasing the skill and consistency La Baguette is known for. With years of culinary expertise under their belt, this cheesecake stands out as a true gem in the Springs.

Pair it with a cup of their delightful espresso, and you have a match made in dessert heaven! If you're in search of a low-key meal that indulges your sweet cravings, look no further than La Baguette Cafe—you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Colorado Springs.

Caffeinated Cow

Highlights
Locally owned establishment
Fresh, healthy meals
Friendly and helpful staff
Accessible menu options
Great brunch spot

Caffeinated Cow is an unassuming gem in Colorado Springs, where the aroma of freshly brewed coffee beckons you upon entry. As a lover of all things cheesecake, this cozy spot piqued my interest with its delightful offerings. The first bite of their cheesecake was nothing short of a revelation—creamy and dense, it had a well-balanced sweetness that complemented its rich texture. You could tell this dessert was made with care, featuring high-quality ingredients.

What truly sets Caffeinated Cow apart is the friendly and attentive staff. They enthusiastically shared their passion for every item on the menu, making me feel right at home. Besides cheesecake, their brunch options and fresh, healthy meals rounded out a menu that appeals to many palates.

While indulging in a slice of cheesecake, paired perfectly with their expertly crafted coffee, I couldn’t help but feel the vibrant community spirit that makes this place special. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Caffeinated Cow is a must-visit for cheesecake lovers. Come for the cheesecake, stay for the ambiance, and leave with a smile—it’s a uniquely satisfying experience!

You might also want to check out the best carrot cake in Colorado Springs Cream Cheese Frosting.

Death By Cheesecake

Death By Cheesecake truly lives up to its name, enticing diners with a creamy indulgence that feels almost sinful. The moment I took a bite, the velvety texture and rich flavor enveloped my senses, sending me straight to dessert heaven. Each slice is a masterpiece, boasting gourmet toppings and innovative flavors that are both playful and sophisticated. Don't miss the chocolate bliss or the fruity raspberry swirl—each bite is a delightful surprise! If you’re looking for a place that elevates cheesecake to an art form, this spot is an absolute must-visit in Colorado Springs. Prepare for a deliciously decadent experience!

You might also want to check out the best carrot cake in Colorado Springs Cream Cheese Frosting Recipe.

Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery

Nestled in the heart of the city, Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery tantalizes taste buds with their signature cheesecake. This luscious treat pairs a velvety texture with a perfectly balanced sweetness that dances on the palate. The crust, a buttery symphony of graham cracker crumbs, complements the cheesecake's rich filling beautifully. Each bite feels like a warm embrace, making it hard to resist back-to-back servings. With its charming ambiance and delightful aroma, this bakery deserves a spot on your dessert itinerary. Make sure to indulge in this creamy delight—it's a slice of heaven you don’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Colorado Springs.

Wimberger's Old World Bakery and Delicatessen

Wimberger's Old World Bakery and Delicatessen is a hidden gem that truly delivers when it comes to cheesecake. Their New York-style cheesecake is a delight—smooth, creamy, and perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness. As I savored each bite, the crust provided a satisfying crunch that contrasted beautifully with the soft filling. The ambiance of the bakery adds to the charm, making it a perfect spot for a sweet escape. If you're on a quest for the ultimate cheesecake experience in Colorado Springs, do yourself a favor and indulge in Wimberger's—it’s a slice of bliss!

You might also want to check out the best salads in Colorado Springs.

Norma’s Bakery

At Norma’s Bakery, the moment I entered, the sweet aroma of baked delights enveloped me. Their cheesecake is a delightful revelation; each bite offers a creamy, velvety texture that dances on the palate. The classic New York style has just the right amount of tanginess, complemented perfectly by the buttery graham cracker crust. I indulged in their seasonal berry topping, which added a burst of freshness that elevated the dessert. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make this a must-visit spot for any cheesecake lover in the Springs. Who knew bliss could come in such a delicious slice?

You might also want to check out the best breakfast burrito in Colorado Springs.