The Absolute Best Pies in Colorado Springs [Updated 2025]

Each bite of a perfectly baked pie tells a story, and let me tell you, I’ve tasted some incredible tales right here in Colorado Springs. After indulging in sweet and savory slices at twelve top locations, I can confidently say that my taste buds have never been happier.

As someone who thrives on finding hidden gems and delicious delights, I’ve made it my mission to sift through the pie panorama of our beautiful city. Whether you're a lifelong resident or just passing through, my insights will guide you to the most mouthwatering crusts and fillings that will leave you craving more. Get ready to embark on a pie adventure like no other!

Gold Star Bakery

Highlights
Incredible coconut custard pie
High-quality, delicious pies
Small storefront charm
Worth the splurge
Must-try for pie lovers

Gold Star Bakery is an absolute gem tucked away in Colorado Springs, charmingly quaint and brimming with delicious temptations. As soon as I stepped inside, the warm aroma of baked goods enveloped me, luring me toward the display cases showcasing their stunning pie selection.

I couldn't resist trying their incredible coconut custard pie—a true standout! Each slice was a delightful combination of creamy perfection and a hint of tropical flair, making my taste buds dance with joy. The rich, velvety custard was perfectly balanced, while the toasted coconut topping added that wonderful crunch.

In this cozy little storefront, it’s clear that quality is at the forefront. Gold Star Bakery truly offers high-quality, delicious pies that are well worth the splurge. The warmth of the environment paired with their mouthwatering creations makes for a delightful experience whether you’re stopping in for a quick treat or planning a gathering.

For those calling themselves pie lovers, Gold Star Bakery deserves a spot on your must-visit list. Trust me, once you've had a taste of their pies, your dessert expectations will never be the same!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Colorado Springs.

Mary's Mountain Cookies

Highlights
Amazing cookie aroma
Variety of cookie options
Nicely baked and portioned
Cute and fancy presentations
Mixed freshness experience

While I primarily sought the finest pies, I couldn't help but be drawn into the phenomenal world of cookies that Mary's Mountain Cookies offers. The moment I stepped into this delightful cookie haven, the amazing aroma enveloped me like a warm hug. The sheer variety of cookie options here is enough to spark a sweet tooth’s imagination. From classic chocolate chip to uniquely themed seasonal bites, the choices are abundant and utterly tempting.

What truly sets these cookies apart is their artful presentation. Each one looks like a tiny work of art, expertly baked and perfectly portioned. It feels like they’ve taken all the love and care usually reserved for pies and infused it into these cookies.

However, I did sense a slight inconsistency in freshness. While some cookies were heavenly, others didn't quite hit the mark. Still, when you find a batch that’s just right, they might as well be served at a dessert gala!

So, while I may have been on the hunt for pie, I left with a newfound love for cookies. If you find yourself in Colorado Springs, treat yourself to Mary's Mountain Cookies. They may not have pies, but these gems are sure to delight!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Colorado Springs.

Marigold Cafe & Bakery

Highlights
Excellent food and service
Attentive and friendly staff
Phenomenal brownie cheesecake
Memorable anniversary experience
Great French Onion soup

Review of Marigold Cafe & Bakery

Stepping into Marigold Cafe & Bakery feels like a warm hug on a crisp Colorado day. The moment I entered, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly baked pastries and a friendly smile from the staff. Their attentiveness truly sets the tone for a wonderful experience. While their pies are the stars of the show, I couldn’t resist trying the phenomenal brownie cheesecake—a dessert that has left an indelible mark on my taste buds.

Now, let’s talk pie! The crust is perfectly flaky, cradling luscious fillings that are bursting with flavor. I opted for a classic cherry pie, and it was a sweet symphony of tart cherries and buttery dough that reminded me of summer days spent picking fruit. The balance was just right, making each bite a genuine delight.

And let’s not overlook the great French Onion soup—a comforting complement to my meal, warming me from the inside out. Marigold Café is not just a place to grab a slice; it’s an experience to savor, perfect for any celebration or a simple treat after a long day. I left with a smile and a promise to return—because when it comes to pies, Marigold truly shines!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Colorado Springs.

Atomic Cowboy home of Denver Biscuit Co & Fat Sully's NY Pizza

Highlights
Late-night dining option
Fantastic and friendly service
Delicious biscuits
Rooftop seating with great views
Highly recommended by locals

Atomic Cowboy, the vibrant home of Denver Biscuit Co & Fat Sully's NY Pizza, is a gem that's not just about late-night cravings but the delightful experience it offers. As I stepped in, the lively ambiance greeted me, setting the stage for a memorable culinary adventure. The friendly service felt like chatting with an enthusiastic friend eager to share their favorite pie.

Being a sucker for unique twists, I couldn't resist trying their famous pizzas. Each slice was an explosion of flavor with a perfectly crisp crust that was just the right amount of chewy. The toppings were fresh and plentiful, making every bite a celebration of expertly combined ingredients. To my surprise, the biscuits they offer also deserve a mention; they were flaky and rich, a perfect accompaniment to my pizza!

And let’s talk about the rooftop seating—picture this: enjoying your pie under the stars with a breathtaking view of Colorado Springs. It’s a vibe!

Local enthusiasts rave about Atomic Cowboy for a reason. If you're in search of a place that combines hearty eats with a casual atmosphere, this is it. I can’t recommend it enough; your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Colorado Springs.

The Sourdough Boulangerie

Highlights
Incredible bread and pastries
Legendary Christmas stollen
Build-your-own pizza options
Knowledgeable and friendly staff
Reasonable prices for all

The Sourdough Boulangerie is a delightful gem in the heart of Colorado Springs. As I stepped inside, the warm aroma of freshly baked goods wrapped around me like a cozy blanket. The incredible bread and pastries are a testament to their mastery in the art of baking, but I was on a mission: to uncover the best pie this charming bakery has to offer.

I had the privilege of indulging in their seasonal fruit pie. Each bite revealed a symphony of flavors, with perfectly balanced sweetness and a flaky crust that seemed to dance on my palate. The knowledgeable and friendly staff added to the experience, suggesting I try the legendary Christmas stollen, which I plan to return for once the holidays roll around.

While they do offer a fun build-your-own pizza option that’s perfect for a relaxed evening, it was the pie that truly captured my heart. Not to mention, the reasonable prices make it easier to treat yourself without guilt. If you haven’t visited yet, I highly recommend this quaint boulangerie for a slice of pie happiness—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Colorado Springs.

Nana's Bakery Inc

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Inviting aroma upon entrance
Beautifully displayed pastries
Mixed reviews on custom cakes
Complimentary treats offered

Nana's Bakery Inc is a delightful gem that completely captivates from the moment you step inside. The inviting aroma of freshly baked goods wraps around you like a warm hug, whisking you away into a world filled with sweet possibilities. As I wandered about, I couldn’t help but admire the beautifully displayed pastries—each pie a work of art with its flaky crust glistening under the bakery lights.

The staff here are nothing short of friendly and welcoming. They greet you with genuine smiles, which instantly makes you feel at home. I struck up a conversation with one of the bakers who eagerly shared stories of their favorite flavors. This personal touch adds so much to the overall experience.

While I indulged in their famous pies, I must confess that I had mixed feelings about their custom cakes; the reviews seem to vary. However, the complimentary treats they offered—think mini cookies as a prelude—were a delightful surprise!

If you’re in Colorado Springs and craving a slice of heaven, don’t miss out on the pies at Nana's Bakery Inc. Each bite is a testament to the passion and creativity that defines this charming spot.

You might also want to check out the best pho in Colorado Springs.

Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders

Highlights
Homey and quaint atmosphere
Best pizza in Colorado Springs
Delicious garlic bread
Great for dine-in or takeout
Inconsistent service timing

Going into Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders, I was immediately charmed by the homey and quaint atmosphere. It felt like stepping into a warm embrace—perfect for a cozy meal! While everyone raves about their pizza, I couldn't resist sampling their signature pie offerings. Each slice of their pies is a delightful dance of flavors, balancing sweet and savory exquisitely.

I kicked things off with their famed garlic bread, and oh my, it was like a cozy hug for my taste buds! The delightful aroma wafting through the air only added to the experience. Whether you’re planning to dine in with friends or grab a quick takeout, this spot accommodates both with ease.

That said, it's worth mentioning that the service timing can be inconsistent. Sometimes you might find yourself waiting a tad longer than expected, but trust me, the meal is well worth the wait. Overall, Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders is a gem that invites you to savor each bite. I wholeheartedly recommend giving it a try—especially if you're on the hunt for the best pies in town! ✨🍕

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Colorado Springs.

Outside The Breadbox

Highlights
Best gluten-free bagels
Delicious sandwich rolls
Awesome gluten-free pizza crust
Kid-approved gluten-free donuts
Friendly and helpful staff

Review of Outside The Breadbox

Stepping into Outside The Breadbox feels like entering a fantastical world of baked delights. As a pie enthusiast, I was originally drawn in by their gluten-free offerings, which I often find to be hit-or-miss, but here, it’s a home run! Among their masterpieces, the pies were particularly noteworthy—though they’re celebrated for their bagels and rolls, the sweet creations rival any traditional dessert offerings.

I took a moment to savor their seasonal fruit pie, and the flaky crust was a triumph of texture—golden brown, with just the right balance of crispiness and softness. The filling sang with the freshness of the fruits, dancing on the palate in a way that made the bites impossible to resist.

What truly stood out was the incredibly friendly staff. They welcomed me with genuine smiles and were eager to share recommendations. It felt like visiting a friend's house rather than a bakery. Overall, if you’re seeking pie in Colorado Springs, Outside The Breadbox is definitely worth a visit. You might just discover your new favorite dessert that’s both delicious and gluten-free!

You might also want to check out the best carrot cake in Colorado Springs Cream Cheese Frosting.

Shuga's

Highlights
Unique atmosphere
Incredible service
Amazing menu options
Super nice staff
Fun eating experience

Shuga's Pie Review

Upon stepping into Shuga's, I was immediately greeted by its unique atmosphere, where hip urban vibes meet cozy comfort. The eclectic decor sets the stage for a delightful dining experience that pairs perfectly with their amazing menu options. As I perused the selections, I was particularly thrilled to find their legendary pies, which are known for being both innovative and exceptionally delicious.

The staff at Shuga's deserve a special mention for their incredible service. Their warmth and attentiveness made me feel right at home, which undoubtedly enhanced my pie tasting experience. I opted for a slice of their lemon meringue pie, the citrus tang cutting through the sweetness in a way that left me dreaming about my next visit.

Every bite was a testament to Shuga's commitment to quality, making it a must-visit for pie lovers in Colorado Springs. Whether you’re looking to indulge in a piece of fruit-filled heaven or simply enjoy a fun eating experience with friends, Shuga’s has you covered. In a city brimming with pie options, this establishment shines distinctly, proving that they truly know how to craft a slice worth savoring.

You might also want to check out the best carrot cake in Colorado Springs Cream Cheese Frosting Recipe.

Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery

I recently indulged in a delightful slice at Boonzaaijer's Dutch Bakery, where each pie tells a story of rich tradition. Their Dutch Apple Pie is a tapestry of flavors, with spiced apples enveloped in a flaky crust that crumbles beautifully with each bite. The hand-crafted approach shines through, making it feel like a warm hug on a plate. I also couldn't resist their Cherry Pie, bursting with juicy cherries that sing in harmony with just the right amount of sweetness. If you're on the hunt for a pie that feels like home, Boonzaaijer's is an absolute must-visit in Colorado Springs! 🍏🥧🍒

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Colorado Springs.

3.14 Pi Bar

At 3.14 Pi Bar, every slice is a whimsical delight. The moment I stepped in, the aroma of freshly baked pies wrapped around me like a warm embrace. I tried their classic apple pie, which boasted a perfect balance of tartness and sweetness under a flaky, golden crust. The chocolate silk pie was an indulgent treat, rich and creamy, leaving me eager for another bite. With a quirky, math-themed decor and a playful vibe, this spot makes pie tasting feel like a delicious adventure. If you're hunting for the best pie experience in Colorado Springs, make sure 3.14 Pi Bar is on your list! 🍰

You might also want to check out the best salads in Colorado Springs.

Sweet Elizabeth's Organics

From the moment I stepped into Sweet Elizabeth's Organics, I was enveloped in warm aromas that beckoned me closer. I sampled their signature peach pie, and oh my, the juicy filling surrounded by a perfectly flaky crust was a revelation! Each bite was a dance of flavors, balancing sweetness with a hint of tartness. The use of organic ingredients truly made a difference; it felt like heaven on a plate. I also couldn’t resist their chocolate cream pie, which was decadently rich and utterly satisfying. For anyone craving a slice of joy, this charming bakery is a must-visit! 🍑🥧

You might also want to check out the best breakfast burrito in Colorado Springs.