The Absolute Best Pizza Places in Colorado Springs

Let’s be honest: you moved here for the views, but you stay for the crust. Colorado Springs has quietly become a pizza town, and the range is gloriously absurd—from a 26-inch New York behemoth at Atomic Cowboy to the Detroit-style, caramelized-cheese edges at Decent Pizza Co.

We ate our way through every slice, deep-dish, and garlic knot (the pesto-drizzled ones at Atomic Cowboy nearly ended us). Whether you’re chasing a rooftop sunset with hot honey or a no-frills slice at an Ivywild counter, this city delivers.

Your next favorite pie is below.

Stellina Pizza Cafe

Highlights
Thin, fresh, elegant crust
Unreal crust, simple toppings
Great value for quality
Amaretto sour unexpectedly delicious
Casual spot, big portions

Stellina Pizza Cafe nails the basics beautifully. You walk in, order at the counter, and the thin, elegant crust arrives with just the right char. It's crispy, airy, and honestly, the star of the show. The toppings stay simple, letting the dough shine. Great value here, too — big portions for a fair price. Start with the amaretto sour; it’s unexpectedly smooth and pairs well with the savory pie. The space is casual, bright, and perfect for a weeknight bite. If you want pizza that respects tradition without fuss, Stellina delivers.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Lakewood.

Pizzeria Leopold

Highlights
Top-three pizza since Italy
Rooftop deck with sunset views
Zero-proof cocktails are lovely
Hot honey pizza and perfect crust
Homemade cannoli, not too sweet

Pizzeria Leopold feels like a slice of Italy dropped into Colorado Springs. The crust alone deserves a standing ovation — thin, blistered, and impossibly light. I'd rank it among the top three pizzas I've had since my last trip to Naples. Sit on the rooftop deck as the sun sets; the views stretch over the city, and the vibe turns golden and relaxed. Their zero-proof cocktails are lovely, especially the citrusy one with herbs. The hot honey pizza adds a sweet kick against the perfect crust. Finish with a homemade cannoli — not too sweet, just right.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Pueblo.

Atomic Cowboy home of Denver Biscuit Co & Fat Sully's NY Pizza

Highlights
Massive 26-inch pizza pies
Garlic knots with pesto drizzle
Buffalo wings that deliver
Breakfast biscuits from Denver Biscuit Co
Warm staff, cold beer

Atomic Cowboy is a beast of a place. They serve massive 26-inch NY-style pies that feed a crowd — or just you, if you're ambitious. The garlic knots with pesto drizzle are dangerously good; soft, buttery, and gone in minutes. The buffalo wings deliver real heat with a tangy kick, and they stay crispy even under sauce. Don't skip the breakfast biscuits from Denver Biscuit Co — they're fluffy, loaded, and available all day. The staff is warm, the beer is cold, and the whole vibe is loud, fun, and unpretentious. Bring friends, stretchy pants, and a big appetite.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Castle Rock.

Billy's Old World Pizza

Highlights
Deep dish worth the wait
Owner Jim’s gracious service
Generous spirit, free meal
Old arcade game charm
Sausage pizza, garlic sticks shine

Billy's Old World Pizza is old-school charm done right. The deep dish is worth the wait — thick, cheesy, and baked to perfection. Owner Jim greets you like an old friend, and his gracious service makes you feel at home. There's a generous spirit here: the portions are huge, and they're not shy with toppings. The arcade games in the corner add a nostalgic touch that kids and adults both enjoy. The sausage pizza is a classic, and the garlic sticks shine with a buttery, herby crust. It's not fancy, but it's honest, satisfying, and totally memorable.

You might also want to check out the best bar in Lakewood.

Decent Pizza Co.

Highlights
Best Detroit-style in town
Divine, crunchy crust edges
Lovely, cheerful staff
Worth a stop at Ivywild

Decent Pizza Co. might have a modest name, but the pizza is anything but. This is the best Detroit-style pie in town, hands down. The crust is divine — thick, airy, and with a crispy, caramelized cheese edge that snaps. The staff is lovely and cheerful, making the whole experience feel warm and welcoming. It's tucked into the Ivywild area, which is worth a stop on its own for the community vibe. Go for the classic pepperoni or a specialty; you can't go wrong. The sauce is bright, the cheese is generous, and every bite is comfort. Just go.

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Colorado Springs.

Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders

Highlights
Friday-night regulars’ top choice
Live music, fun crowd
Manager checks every custom order
Online ordering is effortless
Worth the drive east

Colorado Springs Pies and Grinders is the Friday-night spot locals keep secret. The regulars come for the live music and the fun crowd, and they stay for the consistently solid food. The manager checks every custom order personally — a rare touch that shows real care. Online ordering is a breeze, so you can skip the line and grab your pie fast. The grinders are hefty, but the pizza steals the show: crispy crust, robust sauce, and a perfect cheese pull. It's a little east of downtown, but absolutely worth the drive. Casual, lively, and reliably delicious.

You might also want to check out the best places to visit in Colorado Springs.

Upstate Pizzeria

Highlights
Killer wings steal the show
Genuine New York style pies
Host Richie makes you welcome
Bar perfect for friend hangs
Crispy knots worth the walk

Upstate Pizzeria brings genuine New York style to Colorado Springs. The wings are killers — crispy, juicy, and slathered in a sauce that has just the right burn. The pies are thin, foldable, and loaded with quality toppings. Host Richie makes you feel like a regular from the moment you walk in, even on your first visit. The bar is perfect for hanging with friends, pouring local brews and classic cocktails. Don't skip the crispy knots on the side; they're worth the walk from anywhere. It's a straightforward, no-nonsense spot that does everything well. Simple and satisfying.

You might also want to check out the best views in Colorado Springs.

Black Forest Pies & Grinders

Highlights
Best pizza in town
Amazing calzones, great sausage
Fresh food, friendly service
Worth the price, easily
Fun soda choices for kids

Black Forest Pies & Grinders claims the title for best pizza in town, and honestly, it's hard to argue. The crust is perfect — chewy, blistered, and full of flavor. The calzones are amazing, stuffed to the brim and baked until golden. The sausage has a nice fennel kick that pairs beautifully with the fresh mozzarella. Everything tastes fresh, and the service is friendly without being overbearing. Prices are fair for the quality, and kids will love the fun soda options with quirky flavors. It's a family-friendly spot that doesn't cut corners. You'll leave full, happy, and already planning your next visit.

You might also want to check out the best dog groomers in Colorado Springs.

Joey's NY Pizza

Highlights
Window-shop your pizza
Custom toppings, fantastic crust
Nolan's friendly first-time service
Pepperoni rolls worth ordering

Joey's NY Pizza lets you window-shop while you wait — which is perfect because the pies deserve a preview. You can stare at the custom toppings and watch them assemble your order fresh. The crust is fantastic: crisp on the outside, soft inside, and with that perfect chew. Nolan at the counter was friendly and patient on my first visit, even with my indecisiveness. The pepperoni rolls are an unexpected win — flaky, savory, and addictive. It's a straightforward NYC-style spot with no frills, just solid pizza done right. Grab a slice, find a seat, and enjoy the simplicity.

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Centennial.

Hatch Cover

Highlights
Crab-stuffed mushrooms worth signing up for
Top-notch friendly, hardworking service
Delicious daily specials, zero spam
Hot, perfectly cooked American fare
Great bar games, TVs, fair prices

Hatch Cover is a hidden local favorite that flies under the radar. The crab-stuffed mushrooms are worth signing up for alone — rich, briny, and perfectly baked. Service is top-notch, with a hardworking team that anticipates your needs. The daily specials are always delicious, and they change often enough to keep things interesting. There's zero spam here — just honest, hot, perfectly cooked American fare. The bar has great games and TVs, so it's easy to settle in for a game or a casual evening. Prices are fair, and the vibe is relaxed. A reliable choice for a no-fuss, tasty meal.

You might also want to check out the best shopping malls in Colorado Springs.

The Joint

Highlights
Diverse, innovative, generously portioned dishes
Killer vegan Reuben with pastrami
Excellent jackfruit sandwich execution
Creative fried apps worth trying

The Joint is a surprise in the best way. The menu covers diverse ground, and every dish arrives generous and inventive. The vegan Reuben with jackfruit is a showstopper — smoky, tangy, and satisfying even for carnivores. The excellent jackfruit sandwich execution makes you wonder why more places don't try this. Creative fried apps, like crispy cauliflower with a spicy aioli, are worth the trip alone. Portions are huge, so come hungry. The space feels cozy and unpretentious, with friendly staff who actually seem excited about the food. A solid pick for adventurous eaters.

You might also want to check out the best roofers in Colorado Springs.

Mash Mechanix Brewing Co

Highlights
Passionate owners, unforgettable memories
True-to-style house beers
Relaxed patio with fire-pits
Pet-friendly, mellow atmosphere
Food truck right next door

Mash Mechanix Brewing Co feels like your neighborhood hangout, but with seriously good beer. The owners are passionate, and you can taste it in every pour — true-to-style, crisp lagers and bold IPAs. The patio is relaxed, scattered with fire pits that make cool evenings perfect for lingering. Dogs are welcome, which adds to the mellow, friendly vibe. There's a food truck right next door, so you can grab a bite and pair it with your pint. The service is warm, and the memories you make here stick. It's unpretentious, genuine, and worth a regular spot in your rotation.

You might also want to check out the best veterinarian in Colorado Springs.