The Absolute Best Reuben Sandwich in Colorado Springs [Updated 2025]

After countless bites, I’ve sampled 12 of the top contenders in the city, each one bringing its own twist to this classic deli delight. From the perfectly toasted rye to the tangy sauerkraut and melty Swiss, I’ve honed in on what makes a reuben truly special.

Having tasted these sandwiches from every nook and cranny, I promise you’ll find a worthy spot that will have your taste buds dancing. Whether you're a lifelong local or just passing through, trust me—this is the ultimate guide to satisfying that reuben craving right here in Colorado Springs. Let's dive into the deliciousness!

Colonel Mustard's Sandwich Emporium

Highlights
High quality ingredients
Friendly and attentive staff
Unique menu options
Mustard ice cream experience
Locally adored sandwich shop

Colonel Mustard's Sandwich Emporium is a delightful find tucked away in Colorado Springs, and I must say, their Reuben sandwich truly surpassed my expectations. From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted by a friendly and attentive staff, whose passion for their craft was evident.

The sandwich itself boasted high quality ingredients, with perfectly melted Swiss cheese cascading over a generous layer of tender corned beef. The house-made sauerkraut added a delightful tang, beautifully complementing the rich, buttery rye bread that was toasted to perfection. Each bite felt like a warm embrace, and I savored the balance of flavors that made this sandwich sing.

But the adventure didn’t stop there; I couldn't resist trying their unique offerings, including the curious mustard ice cream as a quirky side to my meal. Surprisingly well-executed, it was a playful finish that made me smile.

In a town filled with options, Colonel Mustard's truly stands out as a locally adored sandwich shop that I enthusiastically recommend to any food lover on the hunt for the best reuben in Colorado Springs.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Colorado Springs.

Hammond's Pastrami & Smoked Delicatessen

Highlights
Incredible smoked deli sandwiches
Tasty and tender roast beef
Exceptional customer service
Fun and sanitary environment
Open five days a week

Ah, the quest for the perfect Reuben in Colorado Springs led me to Hammond's Pastrami & Smoked Delicatessen, and let me tell you—it did not disappoint! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by an exceptional staff whose enthusiasm matched the delicious aroma of smoked meats wafting through the air.

I ordered the Reuben, and it arrived perfectly assembled, showcasing incredible layers of flavor. The corned beef was tender and sliced to perfection, and the generous helping of Swiss cheese melted delightfully atop. Like a gentle embrace, the warm marble rye held everything together, inviting every bite. Hammond's takes great pride in their ingredients, and it shows—each element played its part harmoniously, creating a symphony of flavors that left my taste buds dancing.

Not only did I enjoy my meal, but the sanitized and fun atmosphere made it a pleasant spot to relax for lunch. With their doors open five days a week, I’m already plotting my next visit back. If you’re on the hunt for a truly magnificent Reuben, Hammond's should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Colorado Springs.

Samich Shack

Highlights
Triple meat option available
House sandwich sauce praised
Quality ingredients used
Fresh and soft bread
Exceptional customer service

When I stepped into Samich Shack, I was immediately welcomed by the tantalizing aroma of freshly prepared ingredients. My eyes narrowed in on their Reuben sandwich, and let me tell you, it was a delightful revelation! This was no ordinary pastrami and sauerkraut combo; it came with a triple meat option that easily made my taste buds dance with joy. The quality of the ingredients was evident: the meat was succulent and packed with flavor, while the bread was fresh and soft, perfectly toasted to hold everything together without becoming soggy.

What truly set this Reuben apart was their house sandwich sauce—a unique touch that brought an exciting twist to the classic flavors. Each bite offered a balance of richness and tang that I just couldn’t resist. To top it all off, the customer service was exceptional, with friendly staff who made me feel right at home. If you’re hunting for the best Reuben in Colorado Springs, chase down Samich Shack. You’ll discover a sandwich that’s not just a meal, but a delightful experience!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Colorado Springs.

Oliver's Deli

Highlights
Favorite sandwich shop
Amazing fresh banana bread
Great food and staff
Quaint and homey atmosphere

At Oliver's Deli, the ambiance is inviting—think a cozy, quaint space where the aroma of freshly prepared dishes fills the air. As I settled into one of the charming booths, I was excited to dig into what many locals fondly claim is the best reuben sandwich in town. When it arrived, it was a sight to behold: perfectly toasted rye bread cradling a generous helping of tender corned beef, a vibrant swirl of sauerkraut, and a luscious layer of melted Swiss cheese.

The first bite was a revelation. Each ingredient sang in perfect harmony, and the richness of the dressing added just the right zing to elevate this sandwich into the stratosphere of flavor. Plus, the staff was not only attentive, but their warm smiles made the experience all the more delightful!

But don’t forget dessert—Oliver's homemade fresh banana bread is a must-try. I left feeling satisfied and eager to return. If you're searching for a sandwich that embodies both classic charm and mouthwatering taste, look no further than Oliver's Deli for the reuben of your dreams.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Colorado Springs.

Olde World Bagel

Highlights
Great Breakfast Options
Top-Tier Sandwiches
A1 Atmosphere
Stunning Pikes Peak Views
Highly Recommended

Review of Olde World Bagel's Reuben Sandwich

Nestled amid the charming streets of Colorado Springs, Olde World Bagel is a delightful stop that caught my attention with its top-tier sandwiches. As I walked in, the aroma of freshly baked bagels filled the air, setting the stage for my eagerly anticipated Reuben.

This establishment isn’t just about breakfast; they craft a medley of flavors that are absolutely enticing. The moment I took a bite of their Reuben, I was greeted by layers of succulent corned beef, perfectly sauerkraut, and a tangy dressing all nestled within toasted rye bread that was crisp yet tender. It was a harmonious experience, with each ingredient singing in glorious unison.

What truly amplifies the experience is the stunning view of Pikes Peak from the patio. Picture this: a sunny Colorado day, savoring the heartiness of a quality sandwich while taking in the majestic mountain backdrop. It’s a slice of Americana that feels just right.

For anyone seeking a highly recommended Reuben, look no further! Olde World Bagel not only delivers on flavors but also provides a cozy atmosphere that keeps you coming back for more.

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Colorado Springs.

Shuga's

Highlights
Unique atmosphere
Incredible service
Amazing menu options
Super nice staff
Fun dining adventure

Shuga's in Colorado Springs: A Reuben to Remember

Walking into Shuga's, I was immediately enveloped by its unique atmosphere that oozes creativity and comfort. The vibrant decor and playful energy set the perfect stage for what I hoped would be a memorable dining adventure. And let me tell you, the experience did not disappoint!

The moment I sat down, I was greeted by the super nice staff, who were more than eager to recommend their favorite dishes. Naturally, I opted for the reuben. As I took my first bite, I was entranced by the beautiful balance of flavors. The house-made corned beef was incredibly tender and expertly seasoned, resting between perfectly toasted rye bread.

What truly set this sandwich apart, however, was the tangy homemade thousand island dressing that added a delightful zing. The generous portions left me feeling satisfied, yet yearning for more.

With an amazing menu that teases your taste buds and service that makes you feel right at home, Shuga's is a must-visit for any reuben lover in Colorado Springs. I left with a happy heart and a full belly, dreaming of my next culinary adventure.

You might also want to check out the best pho in Colorado Springs.

East Coast Deli

At East Coast Deli, the Reuben is an absolute delight! The corned beef is tender, piled high, and brimming with flavor that transports you straight to a New York corner deli. Their house-made sauerkraut adds a perfect tangy crunch, while the thousand island dressing brings it all together in a luscious embrace. The grilled rye is crisped to golden perfection, making each bite a heavenly experience. If you’re hunting for a standout reuben in Colorado Springs, this gem should definitely be on your radar! Trust me, you won't regret treating your taste buds to this masterpiece!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Colorado Springs.

Wooglin's Deli & Cafe

At Wooglin's Deli & Cafe, the Reuben is a delightful blend of flavors that dances on your palate. The tender, slow-cooked corned beef is perfectly piled high, while the homemade thousand island dressing adds a creamy zing. The sourdough bread is skillfully grilled to golden perfection, providing a satisfying crunch with every bite. I particularly appreciated the generous layer of tangy sauerkraut, which complements the meat beautifully. The atmosphere is cozy, making it a perfect spot to indulge your cravings. If you're on the hunt for a standout reuben, Wooglin's is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best carrot cake in Colorado Springs Cream Cheese Frosting.

Grinder Sandwich Co.

At Grinder Sandwich Co., the reuben is a delightful revelation. The flesh of beautifully smoked brisket paired with tangy sauerkraut creates a symphony of flavors that dance on the palate. The house-made Thousand Island dressing adds a creamy richness, while the toasted rye bread provides the perfect crunch. Each bite is a warm hug, inviting and satisfying. The casual atmosphere complements the delectable offerings, making it a perfect spot for lunch. If you’re hunting for a reuben that captivates both heart and taste buds, look no further—Grinder Sandwich Co. is a solid contender in the quest for the best reuben in Colorado Springs!

You might also want to check out the best carrot cake in Colorado Springs Cream Cheese Frosting Recipe.

The Public House

The Public House truly elevates the classic reuben experience! The marbled rye is perfectly toasted, providing a delightful crunch with each bite. The tender corned beef is piled high, complemented by tangy sauerkraut that adds a zing to the flavor profile. I was particularly impressed by the house-made thousand island dressing, which tied everything together beautifully. The portion sizes are generous, making it a satisfying meal for any sandwich lover. If you’re on a quest for the ultimate reuben, this local gem should not be missed! Trust me, your taste buds will thank you.

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Colorado Springs.

Wimberger's Old World Bakery and Delicatessen

Wimberger's Old World Bakery and Delicatessen serves up a seriously satisfying Reuben that dance on the palate! The marbled rye is perfectly toasted, offering a delightful crunch that complements the juicy, tender corned beef. Each bite is generously layered with tangy sauerkraut and a spread of creamy, homemade Russian dressing that ties everything together brilliantly. The balance of flavors is expertly crafted, leaving you yearning for more, and the friendly atmosphere adds to the overall charm. If you're hunting for a memorable Reuben experience, Wimberger's is an absolute must-visit! Enjoy every savory mouthful. 🍽️

You might also want to check out the best salads in Colorado Springs.

Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe

The Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe serves a delightful reuben that expertly balances flavors. The corned beef is tender and savory, complemented perfectly by the zesty sauerkraut and creamy Swiss cheese. Nestled between toasted, earthy rye bread, each bite is a heavenly blend of textures and tastes. The hint of thousand island dressing adds a delightful tang that ties everything together. Set against the stunning backdrop of Garden of the Gods, it’s more than just a meal; it’s an experience. For anyone on a quest for the ultimate reuben, this cafe is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast burrito in Colorado Springs.