The Absolute Best Grilled Cheese in Colorado Springs [Updated 2026]

What a journey it’s been! Colorado Springs has some real hidden gems when it comes to this gooey, melty delight. I’ve rolled up my sleeves and tasted my way through 12 top spots, each with their own unique twist on the classic. Trust me, I’ve dissected every bit of crunch and ooze, so you know I’m here to give you the lowdown on where to find the ultimate grilled cheese.

Whether you're a traditionalist who craves the classic cheddar on sourdough or someone looking for a gourmet spin, I’ve got you covered. Get ready to embark on a cheesy adventure that will have your taste buds dancing and your stomach growling!

Shuga's

Highlights
Unique atmosphere
Incredible service
Amazing menu variety
Super nice staff
Fun dining experience

At Shuga's, stepping into the café feels like entering a whimsical dreamland, where comfort meets creativity. The unique atmosphere draws you in, with colorful decor and cozy seating that whispers “stay a while.” Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: the grilled cheese. With a menu bursting with variety, I was spoiled for choice, but the classic grilled cheese drew my attention like a magnet.

As I took my first bite, my taste buds danced with delight. The perfect melty cheese, paired with golden-brown, buttery bread, was pure magic. To top it off, the impeccable service made each moment feel like a personal encounter with culinary artistry. The staff at Shuga's were super nice, taking the time to recommend their favorite spins on this classic — each suggestion welcomed with a grin.

If you’re looking for a fun dining experience, this place truly delivers. Whether you’re a grilled cheese aficionado or just someone in search of good vibes and great bites, Shuga's is a place you shouldn't miss. In the quest for the best grilled cheese in Colorado Springs, this brilliant gem certainly stands out!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Colorado Springs.

Samich Shack

Highlights
Beastly sandwiches
Quality ingredients
Delicious house sauces
Fresh and soft bread
Excellent customer service

Samich Shack is a delightful destination for grilled cheese aficionados like myself, and let me tell you, this place truly delivers on its promise of beastly sandwiches! The moment I stepped inside, the aroma of toasted bread and melted cheese enveloped me, immediately sparking excitement.

What sets Samich Shack apart is its commitment to using quality ingredients. They feature fresh and soft bread that perfectly complements their lavish cheese selections. I sampled their signature grilled cheese, and the delightful combination of flavors was nothing short of heavenly. The delicious house sauces they offer made each bite an adventure, adding a unique twist to the familiar comfort food that I know and love.

Moreover, the staff at Samich Shack were truly exceptional. Their friendly demeanor and willingness to recommend favorites showcased their passion for providing a fantastic dining experience. I left feeling not just satisfied, but eager to return and savor another scrumptious creation. If you're on the hunt for the best grilled cheese in Colorado Springs, look no further than Samich Shack—your taste buds will thank you for it!

You might also want to check out the best sushi in Colorado Springs.

Colonel Mustard's Sandwich Emporium

Highlights
Fantastic food quality
Friendly and attentive staff
Artisanal mustards used
Great meatball sandwich
Unique mustard ice cream

Colonel Mustard's Sandwich Emporium is a delightful haven for grilled cheese enthusiasts in Colorado Springs. As I stepped inside, the friendly and attentive staff greeted me with warmth, setting the tone for what would soon become a memorable meal. I decided to try their famed grilled cheese, and let me tell you—every bite was a revelation!

This isn’t just any run-of-the-mill sandwich; the fantastic food quality truly shines through. They use a blend of artisanal cheeses, perfectly melted between freshly baked bread, creating that perfect golden crust we all crave. But what truly sets it apart is the selection of unique mustards available to elevate the sandwich experience. I opted for a zesty Dijon, which complemented the creamy cheese splendidly, adding a delightful tang without overpowering the warm, gooey goodness.

As a bonus, I couldn't resist trying their mustard ice cream for dessert, which was surprisingly delicious! Colonel Mustard's has certainly earned its place among the best grilled cheese spots in town. I left with a smile on my face, already planning my next visit! Truly a must-try for any sandwich lover!

You might also want to check out the best hamburger in Colorado Springs.

Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe

Highlights
Friendly and attentive service
Fresh and flavorful menu
Dog-friendly patio
Amazing truffle oil fries
Great recommendations available

Nestled against the breathtaking backdrop of the Garden of the Gods, the Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe is a delightful surprise for grilled cheese enthusiasts like myself. As I approached, the inviting outdoor patio sang out to me, perfect for a dog-friendly lunch with my trusty companion. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by friendly, attentive staff who made me feel right at home.

Now, let’s talk about the grilled cheese! My choice was their signature creation, which comes oozing with gooey, melted cheeses and a hint of gourmet flair. The sandwich was perfectly toasted, providing that satisfying crunch with each bite. But what truly elevated the experience were their amazing truffle oil fries—a must-have side that I couldn’t resist pairing with my sandwich.

Not only does the cafe boast a fresh, flavorful menu, but the staff also offered great recommendations that made my decision even easier. If you're on the hunt for a whimsical yet satisfying grilled cheese experience, this spot is where you’ll want to go. In short, Garden of the Gods Market and Cafe is a delicious destination that captures the spirit of Colorado Springs.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Colorado Springs.

Colorado Craft Social

Highlights
Outdoor patio experience
Strong local drinks
Amazing nostalgia burger
Fresh Caesar salad
Juicy bison burger

During my recent visit to Colorado Craft Social, I must admit, the grilled cheese had me feeling like a kid again. Nestled in a charming spot with an inviting outdoor patio, this venue offers a playful twist on the classic sandwich, embodying everything we love about comfort food. As I settled in with the sunshine warming my face, I ordered their standout grilled cheese, and let me tell you, it was a cheesy revelation.

The moment I took a bite, I was delighted by the perfectly melted cheese, harmonizing beautifully with the artisanal bread. Each mouthful sparked a wave of nostalgia, reminding me of childhood days spent devouring freshly made sandwiches after a long day of play.

But what truly complemented this delectable delight was the robust selection of local craft drinks that paired beautifully with my meal. To balance out the decadence, I also indulged in a fresh Caesar salad that added just the right touch of crunch.

If you're looking for an unforgettable grilled cheese experience in Colorado Springs, Colorado Craft Social is a must-visit. It's the perfect spot to relish your inner child while sipping on local brews and enjoying a gourmet grilled cheese. Deliciousness awaits!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Colorado Springs.

Toasted Bunz

Highlights
Juicy grilled hot dogs
Friendly and energetic service
Unique burger customization
Satisfying portions
Fun vendor stall atmosphere

Toasted Bunz is a delightful gem in Colorado Springs that elevates the classic grilled cheese to new heights. As soon as I stepped into the vibrant atmosphere, I was welcomed by friendly and energetic service that set a positive tone for my culinary adventure. I couldn't resist sampling their signature grilled cheese, and let me tell you, it did not disappoint.

The satisfying portions of ooey-gooey cheese melted perfectly between golden-brown crispy bread left me craving more. Each bite was a symphony of flavors, bringing back nostalgic memories of childhood lunch hours. Plus, the unique customization options allowed me to craft the ultimate cheesy masterpiece tailored precisely to my taste.

While grilled cheese is the star of the show, the menu also boasts juicy grilled hot dogs and burgers that intrigued my palate as well. In essence, Toasted Bunz captures the spirit of fun with its vendor stall vibe, making it the perfect spot for a casual meal. If you’re on a quest for the best grilled cheese in town, look no further—Toasted Bunz is a heavenly stop that should not be missed! 🧀✨

You might also want to check out the best pho in Colorado Springs.

Mactory Gourmet Mac N Cheese

At Mactory Gourmet Mac N Cheese, I was delighted to discover their innovative take on the classic grilled cheese. The Cheesy Bliss Sandwich features a harmonious blend of three melty cheeses, crisped to perfection on artisanal bread. Each bite was a heavenly symphony of flavors! Their signature addition of truffle oil elevated the dish, making it more than just comfort food—it was an experience. The ambiance buzzed with a fun, vibrant energy that complemented the food. If you're craving a playful twist on the beloved grilled cheese, Mactory is a must-visit! Don’t miss out on this cheesy creation!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Colorado Springs.

Mother Muffs

At Mother Muffs, the grilled cheese experience is nothing short of divine. The moment I bit into their classic combo—perfectly toasted sourdough enveloping a gooey blend of cheddar and Gruyère—I was transported to cheesy bliss. Each mouthful was an exquisite balance of crunchy texture and melting loveliness. What sets them apart is their playful twist with toppings like caramelized onions and jalapeños, adding a kick that dances on the palate. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff only enhance the experience. If you're seeking a grilled cheese that transcends the ordinary, Mother Muffs is your destination!

You might also want to check out the best carrot cake in Colorado Springs Cream Cheese Frosting.

Toastique

At Toastique, the grilled cheese is a delightful twist on a classic comfort food. The cheddar and gouda blend melds perfectly with their house-made sourdough, creating an irresistibly gooey interior. Each bite is a perfect balance of crispy and creamy, elevated by an enticing garlic butter crust. The ambiance is warm and inviting, perfect for cozying up with a sandwich that feels both nostalgic and innovative. Don’t skip the tomato basil soup on the side—it’s the ideal pairing! For grilled cheese aficionados, Toastique presents an experience that’s both comforting and deliciously unique. Highly recommended!

You might also want to check out the best carrot cake in Colorado Springs Cream Cheese Frosting Recipe.

The Public House

At The Public House, I was greeted by a cozy atmosphere that perfectly complemented their mouthwatering grilled cheese selection. I opted for the classic version, which featured ooey-gooey cheddar melted between two slices of perfectly toasted sourdough. Each bite was a delightful interplay of flavors and textures, with a crisp exterior giving way to a warm, cheesy embrace. The slight hint of garlic butter added an extra layer of richness, elevating this sandwich to new heights. Overall, The Public House serves up a grilled cheese that is sure to satisfy your cravings and warm your heart!

You might also want to check out the best thai food in Colorado Springs.

Lebowski's Taproom

Nestled in the heart of Colorado Springs, Lebowski's Taproom is a delightful haven for comfort food lovers. Their grilled cheese is a sublime creation, featuring a perfectly toasted golden-brown exterior that cradles a heavenly mix of gooey cheeses. The moment I took a bite, I was treated to a delightful blend of flavors, artfully complemented by their house-made tomato soup—an ideal dipping partner. With a laid-back ambiance inspired by the classic film, enjoying my meal felt like a scene straight out of a cozy movie night. If you're in the mood for a grilled cheese that feels like a warm hug, this is the place to go!

You might also want to check out the best salads in Colorado Springs.

Grinder Sandwich Co.

At Grinder Sandwich Co., I discovered a grilled cheese that was nothing short of magical. Nestled between perfectly toasted bread, the melty blend of aged cheddar and Gruyère danced with flavors that left me smiling. Each bite revealed a delightful crunch, perfectly balancing with the gooey richness inside. The addition of their house-made tomato soup on the side was a masterstroke, elevating the entire experience. The ambiance was cozy, inviting you to savor each moment. If you’re on the hunt for grilled cheese bliss, be sure to stop by this gem in Colorado Springs. You won’t regret it!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast burrito in Colorado Springs.